Dear all,

I’m using a truncated quantile (median) regression (using `asym_laplace`

) of the type

```
bf(Y | trunc(lb = 0) ~ 1 + x + (1 | id1) + (1 + x | id2), quantile = 0.5),
```

and would like to get conditional effects via `marginal_effects`

. **brms** tells me

`Error: Fitted values on the respone scale not yet implemented for truncated 'asym_laplace' models.`

My question: How difficult and effortful would it be (for me?) to properly implement that functionality and how would I approach this? And if it’s too difficult and effortful, is there a workaround I can use to create the kind of data `marginal_effects`

is producing?

Thanks!

- Operating System: macOS 10.14.6
- brms Version: 2.10.0

What you need is mainly a formula for the mean of a truncated asymmetric laplace distribution.

I wasn’t able to find a closed-form formula online, but I found a numerical solution based on this paper: https://www.jstatsoft.org/article/view/v016c02 (see p. 3)

```
dtrunc <- function(x,
spec,
a = -Inf,
b = Inf,
...)
{
tt <- rep(0, length(x))
g <- get(paste("d", spec, sep = ""), mode = "function")
G <- get(paste("p", spec, sep = ""), mode = "function")
tt[x >= a & x <= b] <-
g(x[x >= a & x <= b], ...) / (G(b, ...) - G(a, ...))
return(tt)
}
extrunc <- function(spec, a = -Inf, b = Inf, ...)
{
f <- function(x)
x * dtrunc(x, spec, a = a, b = b, ...)
return(integrate(f, lower = a, upper = b)$value)
}
```

This then seems to work with **brms**’s `dasym_laplace`

and `pasym_laplace`

```
extrunc("asym_laplace", mu = 1, a = 0)
```

This approach seems generic enough to support any kind of truncated distributions that **brms** already supports in a non-truncated way.

Looking at `vignette("brms_customfamilies")`

it seems to me that the quick fix would be to add a function `fitted_trunc_asym_laplace`

in `fitted.R`

.

```
fitted_trunc_asym_laplace <- function(draws, lb, ub) {
###
}
```

Or would it make more sense to replace `dasym_laplace`

, `pasym_laplace`

, `qasym_laplace`

, and `rasym_laplace`

in `distributions.R`

with versions that can handle truncation? Or is this irrelevant for postprocessing?

Computing the truncated density is not a problem and brms does that already for arbitary models

The remaining problem is the truncated mean. Of course numerical integration, as done in `extrunc`

is always a brute force solution but remember that this needs to be done for each single posterior draws of each single observation, which will be highly inefficient.

OK. Then simply focussing on the use case of me creating a workaround (where I accept the inefficiency of the numerical approach), that is, not a general solution for **brms**, would it be sufficient to implement it in

```
fitted_trunc_asym_laplace <- function(draws, lb, ub) {
###
}
```

?

Yes it should be sufficient.

1 Like

Dear Paul,

Last October above we discussed about how to implement a brute-force method to calculate the expectation of the median of a truncated asymmetric Laplace distribution.

Based on the functions `dtrunc`

and `extrunc`

above (taken from p. 3 of https://www.jstatsoft.org/article/view/v016c02), I’ve defined

```
fnc_exp_median_trunc_asym_laplace <- function(mu, sigma, lb, ub) {
extrunc(
mu = mu,
sigma = sigma,
spec = "asym_laplace",
a = lb,
b = ub,
quantile = .5
)
}
```

and

```
posterior_epred_trunc_asym_laplace <- function(prep, lb, ub) {
mapply(fnc_exp_median_trunc_asym_laplace,
prep$dpars$mu,
prep$dpars$sigma,
lb,
ub)
}
```

which computes when I apply it.

But I realize that I do not yet properly handle or understand `prep$dpar$mu`

and `prep$dpar$sigma`

, since they may differ in length (or rather dimensions) depending on the model fitted.

Is there an another example in posterior_epred.R you can point me to better understand this and possibly even adapt to my use case?

I’m aware that I haven’t yet provided a MRE, so if you think one would be useful here, please let me know.

Thanks!

Perhaps the code used in https://github.com/paul-buerkner/brms/blob/master/R/posterior_predict.R, especially the use of the `get_dpar`

function could be helpful in your setting.

1 Like

Thanks a lot for the pointer!